Review : Heroine Make Quick Eyeliner in #01 Black

Hi guys!
Sharing a review of this eyeliner I received when I attended the brand launch of Heroine Make at SM Mall of Asia last September...

Review : Heroine Make Quick Eyeliner in #01 Black Php 345.00
Here is the product info on the packaging:

It claims to be waterproof, has intense pigmentation, and also gentle for the area around the eyes. These claims got me excited and I guess also gave me higher expectations.

So let's check first the appearance of the product. It has a hot pink packaging. Very girly, so me (although I'm not really into hot pinks)!

It's a twist-up eyeliner so no need to sharpen! It's very easy to use!

At the end, it has a smudger to create a more subtle finish or to create very awesome smokey eyes.

This is the full length of the product.

Here is a swatch on my hand
It does give intense pigmentation. It's dark and it can go darker as you layer it. I like that it's thin so you can easily create thin lines.
Below are pictures of my eyes with the product applied:

I can create a fine cat eyes using this pencil. I actually find it hard to have a precise eyeliner wing using pencil but this one made it very easy for me.
But what I noticed at first stroke is that it's hard and dry and it's quite difficult for me to swatch it, especially around my eye area.
I also don't find it to be waterproof. Water resistant, yes. Not much of an issue for me but the thing is, it gets ruined with oil easily... and I have oily lids. So it gets all over my lids once it gets oily resulting to a ruined eye makeup. :( I can try to stall my lids from getting oily by using a good primer and powder eyeshadow but I guess it's better to just stick with better liners for the top lash line.
But applied at the bottom lash line, it works great. It can stay for a good four hours! I agree with the "Never Get Defeated by Tears" line on the label. :P
This product never caused me irritations although the hardness and dryness feels very uncomfortable because I feel like my skin around the area is getting pushed and pulled when I apply this.
So let's summarize:
What I LIKE:
- Pigmentation - Can create thin, precise lines - Packaging - Water-resistant - No irritations - Locally available - Comes with a smudger - Sort of affordable
What I DON'T LIKE:
- Product is hard and dry - Smudges easily once my lids get oily

Would I repurchase? I don't think so. Though the cons are just a couple, they are a serious matters to me, so I would skip this product. I am interested in the liquid eyeliner though!
And that's my review! I hope this was helpful in some way! :)
What do you think of the Heroine Make Quick Eyeliner in #01 Black?

Cheers,
DAWN