Bito-Onon vs. Hon. Fernandez

Bito-Onon vs. Hon. Fernandez

GR No. 139813

Facts:

​Bito-Onon is the duly elected BarangayChairman of Tacras, Narra Palawan and is the Municipal Liga Chapter President for the Municipality of Narra, Palawan. RespondentQuejano Jr., on the other hand, is the duly elected Barangay Chairman of Rizal, Magsaysay, Palawan and is the Municipal LigaChapter President of Magsaysay, Palawan. BothBito-Onon and Quejano were candidates for the position of Executive Vice- President in the August 23, 1997 election for the Liga ng BrgyProvincial Chapter in the province of Palawan.Bito-Onon was the proclaimed winner prompting Quejano to file a a post proclamation protest with the Board of Election Supervisors (BES), which was decided against him. Not satisfied with the decision of BES Quejano filed a petition for review of the decision of BES. On 1999, Onon filed a petition to dismiss the review raising the issue of jurisdiction. The latter claimed that RTC has no jurisdiction to review the BES’ decision in any post proclamation electoral protest in connection with the 1997 Liga ng mga Brgy Election of Officers and Directors . In his motion to dismiss, Bito-Onon claimed that the Supplemental Guidelines for the 1997 guidelines for the Liga ng Brgy Election issued by the DILG in its Memorandum Circular No. 97-193, providing for review of decisions or resolutions of the BES by the regular courts of law is an Ultra Vires act and is void for being issued without or in excess of jurisdiction, as its issuance is not a mere act of supervision but rather an exercise of control over the Liga’sInternal Org.

Issue:

1.​Whether or not the President’s supervision extend to the Liga ng Baragay which is not an LGU.

2.​Whether or not the guidelines/provision in the Memorandum issued by the DILG within its supervisory limit.

Ruling:

1.​Yes, DOJ ruled that the Liga ng Brgy is a government org., being an association federation/league/union by law or authority of law whose members are either appointed or elected gov’t officials. The ligas are primarily governed by LGC. However, their respective constitution and by-laws shall govern all matters affecting the internal org of the liga not otherwise provided for in the LGC, provided that such consti and by laws shall be supplementary to Book II Title VI OF LGCodeand shall conform to Consti and existing laws.

2.​No, In authorizing the filing of petition for review of BES decision with regular courts under MC No. 97-193, the DILG Secretary in effect amended and modified the guidelines promulgated by the Liga which provides that review of BES decision is with Nat’l LigaBoard. The amendment of the guidelines is more than the exercise of supervision but is an exercise of the power of control which the President doesn’t have over the Liga